Avoids UBSan warning (among other similar ones in SDL_thread.c):
src/thread/SDL_thread.c:109:13: runtime error: index 1 out of bounds for type 'struct (unnamed struct at src/thread/SDL_thread_c.h:70:5)[1]'
SUMMARY: UndefinedBehaviorSanitizer: undefined-behavior src/thread/SDL_thread.c:109:13
(cherry picked from commit f9395a766f)
We should wait for the state to stabilize before SDL_ShouldQuit() returns.
For example:
Thread A initializes and increments a use refcount
Thread B skips initializing and increments the use refcount
Thread B starts cleaning up and checks the use refcount
Thread A starts cleaning up, returns because SDL_ShouldQuit() returns false (not initialized), not touching the use refcount
Thread B returns because the use refcount isn't zero
Now we have the state where the refcount is greater than one and both thread A and B have attempted to cleanup.
With this change:
Thread A initializes and increments a use refcount
Thread B skips initializing and increments the use refcount
Thread B starts cleaning up and decrements and checks the use refcount
Thread A starts cleaning up, waits for thread B
Thread B returns because the use refcount isn't zero
Thread A continues and decrements and checks the use refcount, and finishes cleaning up because it has reached 0.
We require stdbool.h in the build environment, so we might as well use the plain bool type.
If your environment doesn't have stdbool.h, this simple replacement will suffice:
typedef signed char bool;
Most SDL functions used to indicate success or failure using an int return code. These functions have been changed to return SDL_bool.
Here is a coccinelle patch to change code that previously compared the return value to 0 and changes it to a boolean test:
@ bool_return_type @
identifier func =~ "^(SDL_AddEventWatch|SDL_AddHintCallback|SDL_AddSurfaceAlternateImage|SDL_AddVulkanRenderSemaphores|SDL_BindAudioStream|SDL_BindAudioStreams|SDL_BlitSurface|SDL_BlitSurface9Grid|SDL_BlitSurfaceScaled|SDL_BlitSurfaceTiled|SDL_BlitSurfaceTiledWithScale|SDL_BlitSurfaceUnchecked|SDL_BlitSurfaceUncheckedScaled|SDL_CaptureMouse|SDL_ClearAudioStream|SDL_ClearClipboardData|SDL_ClearComposition|SDL_ClearError|SDL_ClearProperty|SDL_ClearSurface|SDL_CloseIO|SDL_CloseStorage|SDL_ConvertAudioSamples|SDL_ConvertEventToRenderCoordinates|SDL_ConvertPixels|SDL_ConvertPixelsAndColorspace|SDL_CopyFile|SDL_CopyProperties|SDL_CopyStorageFile|SDL_CreateDirectory|SDL_CreateStorageDirectory|SDL_CreateWindowAndRenderer|SDL_DateTimeToTime|SDL_DestroyWindowSurface|SDL_DetachVirtualJoystick|SDL_DisableScreenSaver|SDL_EnableScreenSaver|SDL_EnumerateDirectory|SDL_EnumerateProperties|SDL_EnumerateStorageDirectory|SDL_FillSurfaceRect|SDL_FillSurfaceRects|SDL_FlashWindow|SDL_FlipSurface|SDL_FlushAudioStream|SDL_FlushRenderer|SDL_GL_DestroyContext|SDL_GL_GetAttribute|SDL_GL_GetSwapInterval|SDL_GL_LoadLibrary|SDL_GL_MakeCurrent|SDL_GL_SetAttribute|SDL_GL_SetSwapInterval|SDL_GL_SwapWindow|SDL_GetAudioDeviceFormat|SDL_GetAudioStreamFormat|SDL_GetCameraFormat|SDL_GetClosestFullscreenDisplayMode|SDL_GetCurrentRenderOutputSize|SDL_GetCurrentTime|SDL_GetDXGIOutputInfo|SDL_GetDateTimeLocalePreferences|SDL_GetDisplayBounds|SDL_GetDisplayUsableBounds|SDL_GetGDKDefaultUser|SDL_GetGDKTaskQueue|SDL_GetGamepadSensorData|SDL_GetGamepadTouchpadFinger|SDL_GetHapticEffectStatus|SDL_GetJoystickBall|SDL_GetMasksForPixelFormat|SDL_GetPathInfo|SDL_GetRectUnion|SDL_GetRectUnionFloat|SDL_GetRenderClipRect|SDL_GetRenderColorScale|SDL_GetRenderDrawBlendMode|SDL_GetRenderDrawColor|SDL_GetRenderDrawColorFloat|SDL_GetRenderLogicalPresentation|SDL_GetRenderLogicalPresentationRect|SDL_GetRenderOutputSize|SDL_GetRenderSafeArea|SDL_GetRenderScale|SDL_GetRenderVSync|SDL_GetRenderViewport|SDL_GetSensorData|SDL_GetStorageFileSize|SDL_GetStoragePathInfo|SDL_GetSurfaceAlphaMod|SDL_GetSurfaceBlendMode|SDL_GetSurfaceClipRect|SDL_GetSurfaceColorKey|SDL_GetSurfaceColorMod|SDL_GetTextInputArea|SDL_GetTextureAlphaMod|SDL_GetTextureAlphaModFloat|SDL_GetTextureBlendMode|SDL_GetTextureColorMod|SDL_GetTextureColorModFloat|SDL_GetTextureScaleMode|SDL_GetTextureSize|SDL_GetWindowAspectRatio|SDL_GetWindowBordersSize|SDL_GetWindowMaximumSize|SDL_GetWindowMinimumSize|SDL_GetWindowPosition|SDL_GetWindowRelativeMouseMode|SDL_GetWindowSafeArea|SDL_GetWindowSize|SDL_GetWindowSizeInPixels|SDL_GetWindowSurfaceVSync|SDL_HideCursor|SDL_HideWindow|SDL_Init|SDL_InitHapticRumble|SDL_InitSubSystem|SDL_LoadWAV|SDL_LoadWAV_IO|SDL_LockAudioStream|SDL_LockProperties|SDL_LockSurface|SDL_LockTexture|SDL_LockTextureToSurface|SDL_MaximizeWindow|SDL_MinimizeWindow|SDL_MixAudio|SDL_OpenURL|SDL_OutOfMemory|SDL_PauseAudioDevice|SDL_PauseAudioStreamDevice|SDL_PauseHaptic|SDL_PlayHapticRumble|SDL_PremultiplyAlpha|SDL_PremultiplySurfaceAlpha|SDL_PushEvent|SDL_PutAudioStreamData|SDL_RaiseWindow|SDL_ReadStorageFile|SDL_ReadSurfacePixel|SDL_ReadSurfacePixelFloat|SDL_RegisterApp|SDL_ReloadGamepadMappings|SDL_RemovePath|SDL_RemoveStoragePath|SDL_RemoveTimer|SDL_RenamePath|SDL_RenameStoragePath|SDL_RenderClear|SDL_RenderCoordinatesFromWindow|SDL_RenderCoordinatesToWindow|SDL_RenderFillRect|SDL_RenderFillRects|SDL_RenderGeometry|SDL_RenderGeometryRaw|SDL_RenderLine|SDL_RenderLines|SDL_RenderPoint|SDL_RenderPoints|SDL_RenderPresent|SDL_RenderRect|SDL_RenderRects|SDL_RenderTexture|SDL_RenderTexture9Grid|SDL_RenderTextureRotated|SDL_RenderTextureTiled|SDL_RequestAndroidPermission|SDL_RestoreWindow|SDL_ResumeAudioDevice|SDL_ResumeAudioStreamDevice|SDL_ResumeHaptic|SDL_RumbleGamepad|SDL_RumbleGamepadTriggers|SDL_RumbleJoystick|SDL_RumbleJoystickTriggers|SDL_RunHapticEffect|SDL_SaveBMP|SDL_SaveBMP_IO|SDL_SendAndroidMessage|SDL_SendGamepadEffect|SDL_SendJoystickEffect|SDL_SendJoystickVirtualSensorData|SDL_SetAppMetadata|SDL_SetAppMetadataProperty|SDL_SetAudioDeviceGain|SDL_SetAudioPostmixCallback|SDL_SetAudioStreamFormat|SDL_SetAudioStreamFrequencyRatio|SDL_SetAudioStreamGain|SDL_SetAudioStreamGetCallback|SDL_SetAudioStreamInputChannelMap|SDL_SetAudioStreamOutputChannelMap|SDL_SetAudioStreamPutCallback|SDL_SetBooleanProperty|SDL_SetClipboardData|SDL_SetClipboardText|SDL_SetCursor|SDL_SetFloatProperty|SDL_SetGamepadLED|SDL_SetGamepadMapping|SDL_SetGamepadPlayerIndex|SDL_SetGamepadSensorEnabled|SDL_SetHapticAutocenter|SDL_SetHapticGain|SDL_SetJoystickLED|SDL_SetJoystickPlayerIndex|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualAxis|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualBall|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualButton|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualHat|SDL_SetJoystickVirtualTouchpad|SDL_SetLinuxThreadPriority|SDL_SetLinuxThreadPriorityAndPolicy|SDL_SetLogPriorityPrefix|SDL_SetMemoryFunctions|SDL_SetNumberProperty|SDL_SetPaletteColors|SDL_SetPointerProperty|SDL_SetPointerPropertyWithCleanup|SDL_SetPrimarySelectionText|SDL_SetRenderClipRect|SDL_SetRenderColorScale|SDL_SetRenderDrawBlendMode|SDL_SetRenderDrawColor|SDL_SetRenderDrawColorFloat|SDL_SetRenderLogicalPresentation|SDL_SetRenderScale|SDL_SetRenderTarget|SDL_SetRenderVSync|SDL_SetRenderViewport|SDL_SetScancodeName|SDL_SetStringProperty|SDL_SetSurfaceAlphaMod|SDL_SetSurfaceBlendMode|SDL_SetSurfaceColorKey|SDL_SetSurfaceColorMod|SDL_SetSurfaceColorspace|SDL_SetSurfacePalette|SDL_SetSurfaceRLE|SDL_SetTLS|SDL_SetTextInputArea|SDL_SetTextureAlphaMod|SDL_SetTextureAlphaModFloat|SDL_SetTextureBlendMode|SDL_SetTextureColorMod|SDL_SetTextureColorModFloat|SDL_SetTextureScaleMode|SDL_SetThreadPriority|SDL_SetWindowAlwaysOnTop|SDL_SetWindowAspectRatio|SDL_SetWindowBordered|SDL_SetWindowFocusable|SDL_SetWindowFullscreen|SDL_SetWindowFullscreenMode|SDL_SetWindowHitTest|SDL_SetWindowIcon|SDL_SetWindowKeyboardGrab|SDL_SetWindowMaximumSize|SDL_SetWindowMinimumSize|SDL_SetWindowModalFor|SDL_SetWindowMouseGrab|SDL_SetWindowMouseRect|SDL_SetWindowOpacity|SDL_SetWindowPosition|SDL_SetWindowRelativeMouseMode|SDL_SetWindowResizable|SDL_SetWindowShape|SDL_SetWindowSize|SDL_SetWindowSurfaceVSync|SDL_SetWindowTitle|SDL_SetiOSAnimationCallback|SDL_ShowAndroidToast|SDL_ShowCursor|SDL_ShowMessageBox|SDL_ShowSimpleMessageBox|SDL_ShowWindow|SDL_ShowWindowSystemMenu|SDL_StartTextInput|SDL_StartTextInputWithProperties|SDL_StopHapticEffect|SDL_StopHapticEffects|SDL_StopHapticRumble|SDL_StopTextInput|SDL_SyncWindow|SDL_TimeToDateTime|SDL_TryLockMutex|SDL_TryLockRWLockForReading|SDL_TryLockRWLockForWriting|SDL_TryWaitSemaphore|SDL_UnlockAudioStream|SDL_UpdateHapticEffect|SDL_UpdateNVTexture|SDL_UpdateTexture|SDL_UpdateWindowSurface|SDL_UpdateWindowSurfaceRects|SDL_UpdateYUVTexture|SDL_Vulkan_CreateSurface|SDL_Vulkan_LoadLibrary|SDL_WaitConditionTimeout|SDL_WaitSemaphoreTimeout|SDL_WarpMouseGlobal|SDL_WriteStorageFile|SDL_WriteSurfacePixel|SDL_WriteSurfacePixelFloat)$";
@@
(
func(
...
)
- == 0
|
- func(
+ !func(
...
)
- < 0
|
- func(
+ !func(
...
)
- != 0
|
- func(
+ !func(
...
)
- == -1
)
It was intended to make the API easier to use, but various automatic garbage collection all had flaws, and making the application periodically clean up temporary memory added cognitive load to using the API, and in many cases was it was difficult to restructure threaded code to handle this.
So, we're largely going back to the original system, where the API returns allocated results and you free them.
In addition, to solve the problems we originally wanted temporary memory for:
* Short strings with a finite count, like device names, get stored in a per-thread string pool.
* Events continue to use temporary memory internally, which is cleaned up on the next event processing cycle.
This declares that any `const char *` returned from SDL is owned by SDL, and
promises to be valid _at least_ until the next time the event queue runs, or
SDL_Quit() is called, even if the thing that owns the string gets destroyed
or changed before then.
This is noted in the headers as "the SDL_GetStringRule", so this will both be
greppable to find a detailed explaination in docs/README-strings.md and
wikiheaders will automatically turn it into a link we can point at the
appropriate documentation.
Fixes#9902.
(and several FIXMEs, both known and yet-undocumented.)
This means the allocator's caller doesn't need to use SDL_OutOfMemory directly
if the allocation fails.
This applies to the usual allocators: SDL_malloc, SDL_calloc, SDL_realloc
(all of these regardless of if the app supplied a custom allocator or we're
using system malloc() or an internal copy of dlmalloc under the hood),
SDL_aligned_alloc, SDL_small_alloc, SDL_strdup, SDL_asprintf, SDL_wcsdup...
probably others. If it returns something you can pass to SDL_free, it should
work.
The caller might still need to use SDL_OutOfMemory if something that wasn't
SDL allocated the memory: operator new in C++ code, Objective-C's alloc
message, win32 GlobalAlloc, etc.
Fixes#8642.
